Tapestry Training -- From The Source

Let me help you get your team up to speed in Tapestry ... fast. Visit howardlewisship.com for details on training, mentoring and support!

Monday, June 22, 2009

Speaking on Clojure and Cappuccino as NFJS Seattle

I'll be talking about Clojure and Cappuccino at NoFluffJustStuff Pacific Northwest Software Symposium, which runs from Sept. 18th to the 20th in Redmond, WA.

I seem to have the 'C's covered, but how about the 'T's? If you are attending NFJS or you absolutely, positively, 100% would attend if I was speaking on Tapestry there ... provide some feedback to Jay!

Friday, June 19, 2009

Apache Tapestry 5: State of the Union

I've just uploaded my slide deck from JavaOne this year:

As usual, embedded animations and screencasts don't work, but there's a lot of value here regardless.

This presentation was a slightly extended version of the Webinar.

Thursday, June 18, 2009

Clojure talk from Open Source Bridge

Here's the slides for my Clojure talk at Open Source Bridge:

The upload to SlideShare was confused by parts of the slide deck, but you can follow the gist of it.

Presenting Clojure in 45 minutes is a challenge, and I'll need to be even briefer at OSCON next month.

Tuesday, June 16, 2009

Why choose Tapestry?

I recently had an e-mail exchange with a Tapestry user; after congratulating me on creating Tapestry, he went on with the following observation on his organization:

The company I work at unfortunately chose JSF for their big app. The reason was that Tapestry was "brittle" in the sense that, if one developer breaks something, on a page or a service, very often the whole site won't come up because the initial registry startup will fail. Or for example, if page A has a pagelink to page B, and page B is broken, then page A won't render. While I agree that we shouldn't ship unless the whole app is working, this is a thousands of pages big app with hundreds of mediocre (as in likely to break things) developers. They'd rather have 80% of the thing working than nothing at all. I never thought of this for my own projects, and haven't had the time to examine the truth of their claims. What's your take?

I provided the following response:

Early failures are absolutely, 100%, the only path towards code quality. You may have heard the phrase "no broken windows" (see "The Tipping Point" by Malcom Gladwell for more details) but the short form is that when errors go uncorrected (whether they are broken windows in an abandoned building, or broken code in an application) they tend to multiply quite rapidly.

The things that will "break" a link from page A to page B are substantial problems such as invalid templates, references to unknown properties or components, or compile errors in the page B class ... things that no other developer should ever see when page B's developer is working and checking in code. That is, problems that should never be checked into trunk, but instead kept in a local workspace or a private branch.

An organization that thinks that fail early is a problem is an organization that isn't prepared to develop a large application in any technology. The image I'm getting is one where there is no build server, no continuous integration, at best CVS for source code management (or possibly one of those "shared directory" monstrosities) .... i.e., a chaotic environment where errors are allowed to be checked in to the trunk and can go unnoticed for some time.

The solution to coding errors in pages or components is not to wait until your testers (or end users) find the bugs, but to identify and fix the bugs early. That's called "engineering discipline" and the reality is that even self-professed "mediocre" developers can do it. Tapestry helps because it fails early and has great exception reporting to guide you right the problem so that you can fix it.

Another factor here is enforced helplessness. If only Fred understands page B and he's out when it's broken, then all development stops waiting for Fred to get back. I hit this problem myself, years ago working on a large Struts application (those words give me the heebie jeebies now!). We had lots of code, a fragile and slow build process, and many little code "fiefdoms". I spent too much wasted time twiddling my thumbs.

Nobody should "own the code"; if page B is is broken, Julie (who normally develops page A) should be free to fix it. Julie will need to understand the page B code well enough to fix it, but also you need an overall environment with shared source, no repository locks (that is, nothing that says "Only Fred can change this file"), and no management PHB's getting in the way. Pair programming is the best way for Fred and Julie to share knowledge so that they can understand each other's code. Even if pairing occurs only part time, it's very effective at knowledge transfer as well as ordinary coding.

The idea that "mediocre" developers should use JSF as it is more tolerant of errors is absurd! Tapestry 5 is designed to improve productivity for all developers, by streamlining, simplifying, being smart and being concise ... not to mention live class reloading and best-of-breed exception reporting, which makes it fast to identify and fix those errors.

If your doctor tells you to eat less red meat, that doesn't mean you should switch to a diet of fried chicken three meals a day! Likewise, if you have concerns with code quality from your developers, you should not switch to a less agile, more code-intensive, less supportive development model and hope to catch all the bugs in QA. Sweeping problems under the rug is never a winning strategy.

Coming down off my soap box, I should also add that Tapestry 5.1 works a little bit differently than 5.0 in this respect, so it does (in fact) defer more of the page loading and validation until a link is actually clicked. This is more for performance reasons than to shield developers from application problems. Even in 5.0, the loading and validation was the "reach" from page A to pages explicitly referenced (usually via PageLink during the rendering of page A), so it's a highly unlikely case that a single error in a 1000 page application will keep the application from starting up, unless the start page of the application links to all 999 other pages.

Re-reading the above post I can't emphasize enough: you can't ignore quality problems. Quality problems lead to development failures, schedule slips, missing functionality, low morale and high turnover. Saying "we don't have time to fix the quality problem first" is to ignore the second law of Thermodynamics. You are expecting a miracle, literally writing it into your project plan.

Formos addresses this issue two ways: First, we use Scrum and deliver on (typically) 4 week cycles. Thus we set real deadlines and have a constant check on quality (we're providing working code constantly). We don't even try to predict what we'll be doing six months or two years from now, we just deliver a steady, manageable stream of software.

Secondly, Formos uses Tapestry precisely for all the reasons that the anonymous developer's organization rejected it, and for many, many more reasons besides.

Friday, June 12, 2009

Back from Tapestry 5 Training / Madison, WI

Just got back last night from training in Madison WI. This was primarily an intro to Tapestry 5 for Tapestry 4 developers (and a couple of new-to-web-programming developers) and a lot of hands on pair programming to get them going with their conversion work. It was a lot of fun, and as usual, I learned a bit.

I have a couple of weeks respite now before OSCON which will be followed with training in York, UK, then Estonia, then London.

I'm continuing to hold off on code changes to Tapestry 5, though I hit enough minor annoyances that I'm considering a 5.1 bug fix release before starting 5.2 in earnest.

I have a backlog of work related to Tapestry360 and then my main emphasis is going to be Documentation, Screencasts, Articles, Documentation and Documentation, plus some additional Documentation. It may be a while before I start with new features for 5.2.

Sunday, June 07, 2009

Upcoming Clojure Talks

I'll be speaking about Clojure at Open Source Bridge on June 17th here in Portland.

OSCON 2009

In addition, I'll be speaking on Clojure at OSCON, on July 23rd. OSCON has left its traditional home, Portland, in favor of San Jose, alas. If you are thinking of attending, use my friends, co-workers and family discount code, os09fos, and save 20%.

Tapestry Road Show: Madison, Wisconsin

This week, I'm in Madison, Wisconsin doing some on-site Tapestry training and mentoring. I've been here before and remember it as a pretty cool little college town. In any case, if you want to get together one night this week and chat Tapestry, Java, Open Source, Clojure or anything like that, drop a line!

Monday, June 01, 2009

Vendor Client Relationship Video

This has been making the rounds on YouTube:

As a vendor, I can identify with this ... but I think a lot of clients out there (those not using Formos, for example) are ordering and charged for the Filet and receive the Tacos. Seriously ... multi-year development efforts are a different beast than purchasing a DVD, which is why short iterations and agile development keep everyone's expectations (of both cost and functionality) inline and satisified.

Sunday, May 31, 2009

Back from Training and Portland Code Camp

It's been a rough week ... I still had my sore throat (noticeable during the webinar) when I arrived to do four days of accelerated Tapestry training in Michigan. Returning after midnight on Friday, I had morning and afternoon slots at Portland Code Camp on Saturday to talk about Clojure and Tapestry. I think it was a good little conference, and 75 minute time slots are just barely enough time to say something meaningful.

I attended a nice introduction to jQuery (once again confirming that I backed the wrong horse when selecting Prototype over jQuery for Tapestry), and another session on coding for iPhone.

The only other session I attended was iPhone Development from an ex Softie by Rory Blyth. It was entertaining in an unusual way, since Rory is very glib in a stream of consciousness kind of way, but he spent all but five minutes of his time ranting against Objective-C and iPhone toolkits. Literally he had five minutes for the core of his talk!

I was one of a few people in the audience who knew Objective-C (though it's more than ten years since I coded in it) and found many of his objections quite unreasonable. Basically, he wants Objective-C to look like every other language derived from C, which is missing the point of what Objective-C actually is: a melding of concepts from C and Smalltalk designed to operate on the very constrained hardware available, even for desktops, in the late 80's. It obligates developers to do something unreasonable by today's standards (a cumbersome retain count mechanism, rather than garbage collection), and the (optional) type syntax (such as (NSString *)) reveals its C heritage (as Smalltalk doesn't deal with declared types).

I even made this point to him; that Objective-C may be a natural fit for the constrained devices such as mobile platforms. His response to any challenge from any audience member was that we were afflicted with "Stockholm syndrome".

Strangely, a few minutes after I pointed out the "constrained device" theory (which he dismissed, disjointedly citing Windows smart phones as a "success") he then talked about ... the constraints of the iPhone in terms of memory, battery and CPU utilization.

Basically, Rory is unable to wrap his head around anything unfamiliar or to understand how a difference in philosophy can inform how a language syntax evolves, as well as the terminology (i.e., Objective-C's "receivers", "messages" and "selectors") used to describe that language.

There's a quote from the book Freakonomics, roughly (from memory):

Morality is how we think we should live our lives. Economics reveals how we actually do.

Rory has a kind of "language morality" that states the objects should be listed first, with periods separating member access, such as method invocation, and that languages that deviate from this are failed and broken. Unfortunately for that argument, the explosive success of the iPhone and the iPhone app market indicates that Objective-C is a tremendous development platform for the kind of intuitive, focused, responsive applications that dominate the market.

It was a shame, because his style was entertaining, if very "slacker" styled, and if he organized his thoughts a bit and kept track of the clock, his valid criticisms of the iPhone development environment would hold a bit more weight and reach a wider, more receptive audience.

Tuesday, May 26, 2009

Tapestry 5 Support in IDEA Maia

The next generation of IDEA, Maia will include Tapestry 5 support; this is according to Hugo Palma, who wrote the initial version of the IDEA Tapestry plugin that has been expanded for inclusion in Maia. Cool!

Monday, May 25, 2009

Tapestry & Clojure @ Portland Code Camp

Portland Code Camp is a local (in Portland) free conference on development tools and languages ... and it's coming up fast (this Saturday). I'll most likely be talking about Tapestry and Clojure ... I actually won't know until they make their last minute session selection tomorrow (it's based on how many attendees express interest). If you're in the Portland area and want to learn a bit more about Tapestry or Clojure, sign up and vote!

Sunday, May 24, 2009

Tapestry Road Show: Ann Arbor, Michigan

This week, I'll be in Ann Arbor, MI to do a bit (aka, four grueling days) of on-site Tapestry training. If you're in Ann Arbor and would like to get together for a drink and a chat about Tapestry, Open Source, or anything along those lines, please drop a line!

Wednesday, May 20, 2009

Last call: Tapestry Webinar (Thu May 21)

Formos is sponsoring a live Tapestry Webinar on May 21st. I'll be presenting a 35 - 40 minute introduction to Tapestry 5, followed by live Q&A. I'll be focusing on the big-picture issues about what makes Tapestry useful, unique and fun. If you've been curious about what Tapestry is, or want a chance to ask a question about Tapestry directly, this is a great chance to do it!

Click a link below to register for the Webinar:

Thursday, May 14, 2009

Tapestry 5 Performance Study

Ben Gidley has done a detailed analysis of Tapestry 5 performance He used some quite reasonable assumptions, including running tests for over an hour to gauge memory use over time. His conclusion is that Tapestry performance is excellent, which is a relief if not a surprise.

What I'm really pleased with is that he's demonstrated that Tapestry will perform well under load; more importantly, if a Tapestry application gets "Slashdotted", it may slow down, but it recovers once the wave of requests dies down.

Ben compared a Tapestry application to a Struts application with similar behavior and found that T5 out-performed Struts pretty handily, despite the fact that T5 doubles the number of requests (due to its automatic redirect-after-post behavior).

Thanks for the great work Ben!

Tuesday, May 12, 2009

Clojure @ JavaWorld

Another nice introduction to Clojure is now online: Clojure: Challenge your Java Assumptions at JavaWorld. An introductory Tapestry article is due at JavaWorld shortly as well.

Saturday, May 09, 2009

Apache Tapestry Community Map

Inspired by a map for Clojure, I created a map for Tapestry users:


View Apache Tapestry Users Worldwide in a larger map

Want to add yourself? The map is wide open, something I'll probably regret later.

Update: People have been adding themselves over the weekend, and trends are starting to appear. It seems like adoption is heavier in Europe than in the US (at least, among the narrow set of people who use Tapestry, know about the map, and have actually added themselves). Still, if that sample is true, it begs the question: why? Is it more to do with the European developers, or due to features of Tapestry (such as localization support).

I'm tending towards the former: talking with many Europeans shows that managers have a more "hands off" attitude towards project leaders, who are given more free reign to use tools of choice as long as they deliver. But that's also a horrible generalization from limited data. In fact, a contrary opinion was offered by some developers in Oslo last september ... in Norway, a small number of developers make strong vocal choices (lately, Spring and SpringMVC) and the whole community follows along. But even Europe is a big place which room for many different developer cultures.

Friday, May 08, 2009

Tapestry 5 Webinar: May 21st

Formos is sponsoring a live Tapestry Webinar on May 21st. I'll be presenting a 35 - 40 minute introduction to Tapestry 5, followed by live Q&A. I'll be focusing on the big-picture issues about what makes Tapestry useful, unique and fun. If you've been curious about what Tapestry is, or want a chance to ask a question about Tapestry directly, this is a great chance to do it!

Click a link below to register for the Webinar:

Wednesday, May 06, 2009

Apache Tapestry 5.1 Final Release - 5.1.0.5

The stable release for Tapestry 5.1, release 5.1.0.5, is now available for download.

Tapestry 5.1 includes a large number of improvements to the speed and scalability of Tapestry without sacrificing backwards compatibility. However, you should still consult the upgrade notes that identify a couple of minor "gotchas".

Major improvements from Tapestry 5.0 to Tapestry 5.1:

  • Performance optimizations that speed rendering of very complex pages, and reduce memory usage
  • Static JavaScript libraries will now be dynamically combined into a single request
  • Automatic GZIP compression of static and dynamic content, for clients that support it
  • Significant improvements to Tapestry's property expression language
  • Partial page updates (via Ajax) may now update multiple client-side Zones
  • Many new features and improvements to Tapestry template files
  • Improved client- and server-side validation of numeric input values
  • User's preferred locale is now encoded into the URL, rather than stored in a cookie
  • A new ProgressiveDisplay component for incremental page loading
  • Vastly improved Quickstart Archetype
  • New Tapestry IoC features to make it easier to override services and contributions to service configurations
  • Many new localizations of validation messages
  • Component reference documentation now identifies events triggered by components
  • Really slick new client-side logging facility (based on Blackbird)
  • New API for URL rewriting (to provide improved control over Tapestry URLs)

... and many, many more bug fixes and improvements; full details are available in the release notes.

Download Tapestry 5.1.0.5

Tuesday, May 05, 2009

Clojure: Turns out, parsing is somewhat iterative, not functional

... at least for me. I'm working on some more real-world code in Clojure, and I'm struggling with turning a stream of tokens (representing XML content parsed from a stream) into a DOM-like hierarchy. The tokens represent open tags, attributes, close tags, and text content.

I've written dozens of recursive decent compilers in the past, in Pascal, C, PL/1 and Java. The problem is, that style of compiler works by consuming a stream (of characters or tokens) ... a destructive operation.

Logically, I want code such as:

List parseTemplate(tokens)
{
  result = []

  while (tokens not empty)
  {
    token = pop(tokens)
    if (token.type == text)
    {
      add text token to result;
      continue;
    }

    if (token.type == element)
    {
      e = parse_element (token, tokens)
      add e to result;
      continue;
  }
}

Now, in Clojure I can write a (parse-element) function that takes a bunch of tokens, and it can work its way through the tokens using Clojure's (loop) and (recur) forms ... but to the calling function, tokens will not have changed.

One approach might be to pass along some pretty complex state; literally a state machine (inside a map) so that each function can keep push and popping values into and out of the state before invoking each. This would involve recursing on each token. Anyway, I have a rough idea of what that would look like and it seems complicated.

Instead, I've been pounding my head, looking at Clojure's support for monads. Monad are a way to combine certain types of functions together in a way that appears as if there were mutable state. You provide some base types of monadic functions and, within the context of a monad definition, it streamlines the way those basic monadic functions can be strung together to form more complex monadic functions.

Still trying to wrap my head around the concept however. It gets really confusing because the real power of monads appears when the monadic values, the things returned from a monadic function, are themselves functions. Yep, that's where I get lost too.

Update: passed the initial Monad hurdle; I'm finally beginning to understand them, perhaps even enough to explain them to other people.

Sunday, May 03, 2009

Excellent Clojure Introduction

R. Mark Volkmann has put together a terrific Clojure Introduction. It starts with basic syntax and quickly works through all the core functions, broken out by categories such as "Collections", "Iteration" or "Concurrency".

Very brisk, but full of functions (from the core) that I didn't know of.

For example, here's a function I never noticed before, (get-in), as defined in the Clojure API

(get-in m ks)
returns the value in a nested associative structure, where ks is a sequence of keys

That's accurate, but really encourages you to read the source or experiment in the REPL to see exactly how it works. Worse, its mixed in with hundreds of other functions and really easy to miss (I never noticed it before!).

Here's what the Clojure Introduction says:

To demonstrate this we'll create a map that describes a person. It has a key whose value describes their address using a map. It also has a key whose value describes their employer which has its own address map.

(def person {
  :name "Mark Volkmann"
  :address {
    :street "644 Glen Summit"
    :city "St. Charles"
    :state "Missouri"
    :zip 63304}
  :employer {
    :name "Object Computing, Inc."
    :address {
      :street "12140 Woodcrest Executive Drive, Suite 250"
      :city "Creve Coeur"
      :state "Missouri"
      :zip 63141}}})

The get-in function takes a map and a key sequence. It returns the value of the nested map key at the end of the sequence. The -> macro and the reduce function can also be used for this purpose. All of these are demonstrated below to retrieve the employer city which is "Creve Coeur".


(get-in person [:employer :address :city])
(-> person :employer :address :city) ; explained below
(reduce get person [:employer :address :city]) ; explained below

This is a document to keep linked and to print out and study. Thanks Mr. Volkmann!